TL;DR
Get tools and workshop supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
A House Beautiful report, citing professional organizers, says two familiar decluttering rules may be too rigid: remove an item whenever you buy something new, and discard clothes unworn for a year. The organizers recommend regular household reviews, functional storage, and considering whether clothing suits a person’s current life.
Professional organizers interviewed by House Beautiful say people can reconsider two common decluttering rules: getting rid of one possession for every new purchase and discarding clothing that has not been worn in a year. The advice matters for households trying to maintain order without making every purchase or clothing decision trigger an automatic purge.
The first rule, often called “one in, one out,” ties every new item brought into a home to the removal of another. Organizer Kenika Williams, founder of Tidied by K., told House Beautiful that the approach may work for some people but need not apply to every purchase. She said buyers should instead avoid bringing home items that have no suitable place.
Jayna Lattimore, founder of Ordered Professional Organizing, said decluttering can be a regular practice rather than a reaction to shopping. In her view, periodic sweeps to remove items no longer used or needed can make a purchase-by-purchase purge unnecessary. She also said storage systems should leave some capacity for new belongings; filling every shelf, drawer, or closet can make an organizing system harder to maintain.
The second rule says to let go of clothing that has not been worn for a year. Millie Naor, founder of Bella Organizers, told the publication that some less-used pieces may still be meaningful or worth keeping, while advising people to limit those items. Beth Ruck, founder of Conquering Clutter, said a fixed time limit is not the best measure. She suggested considering whether a garment works with other clothes and whether it fits the owner’s current lifestyle.
A More Flexible Approach to Clutter
The recommendations shift attention from strict deadlines and matching item counts to whether a home’s belongings have usable storage and still serve their owner. That may reduce unnecessary discarding, particularly when a household has room for occasional purchases or keeps clothing for specific uses.
The advice is not that people should stop decluttering. The organizers described in the report still support regular reviews and deliberate decisions about what to keep. Their point is that a rigid rule can prompt a purge even when it does not address the underlying issue: whether an item is useful, wanted, or supported by the home’s storage system.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Rules Under Review
Both rules are simple, memorable ways to limit accumulation: match each new possession with an outgoing one, or use a one-year period to judge clothing. House Beautiful’s report presents them as familiar organizing advice that the interviewed professionals believe can be too inflexible for everyday life.
The report does not compare the rules in a study or claim that all organizers reject them. Williams explicitly said one-in, one-out may suit people for whom it works. The guidance is based on comments from named organizing professionals, rather than research measuring the results of different decluttering methods.
“I don’t think every purchase needs to trigger a purge.”
— Kenika Williams, founder of Tidied by K., as quoted by House Beautiful
No Universal Replacement Rule
The report does not set out a single replacement formula or specify how often households should review their belongings. It also does not establish how much spare storage is appropriate, or quantify whether these approaches lead to better-maintained homes than the rules they challenge.
The advice may not suit every situation. The organizers’ comments leave room for people to keep either rule if it helps them manage clutter. Whether to retain a seldom-worn garment or make room for a new purchase remains a personal decision based on available space, use, and preference.
Apply the Advice at Home
Readers applying the report’s guidance can start by checking whether incoming items have a practical place and by scheduling periodic reviews of what they already own. For clothing, the organizers suggest looking beyond a one-year cutoff: consider whether an item can be worn with other pieces, fits current needs, and merits the closet space it occupies.
House Beautiful’s article offers expert perspectives, not a formal standard or a schedule for future guidance. No further update or follow-up study is identified in the source material.
Key Questions
Which two decluttering rules do the organizers question?
They question one in, one out for every new purchase and the rule to discard clothing that has not been worn in a year.
Are organizers saying people should never use one in, one out?
No. Kenika Williams said people can keep using the rule if it works for them, but she does not think every purchase must trigger a purge.
What should I consider before discarding clothes?
The organizers cited in the report suggest considering whether a garment works with other clothing, suits your current lifestyle, and is worth the space it occupies.
What do the organizers recommend instead of strict rules?
They recommend regular decluttering reviews, making sure new items have a functional place, and leaving some room in storage rather than filling every shelf or closet.
Source: rss
Fall yard work Picks
leaf blowers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
